Michael Strain responds to a recent narrative about the downside of American affluence.

In [Brink] Lindsey’s telling, individuals in rich democracies are overweight, addicted to their phones, and have declining literacy skills, as well as IQ and SAT scores. Compared to past generations, they experience worse mental-health outcomes, have fewer close friends, and spend more time alone and less time having sex. They are also less likely to marry, procreate, and attend religious services, while being more likely to overdose on drugs. These societies exhibit reduced dynamism, slowing productivity growth, rising class divides, and diminishing trust in government and support for liberal democracy.

“To put it bluntly,” Lindsey writes, “society is falling apart.”

Lindsey’s assessment is consistent with post-liberal commentators’ arguments that democratic capitalism is exhausted, a failed experiment and an obstacle to human flourishing.

Capitalism is not exhausted. The argument that it is has a root in the widespread anxiety during the waning years of the last decade about advanced economies’ ability to continue innovating. That concern seems wildly misplaced in our current age of wonders, with GLP-1 drugs for diabetes and weight loss, as well as rapid progress on treatments for life-threatening diseases like Alzheimer’s and cancer. Then there is generative AI, which even the most pessimistic forecasts expect will increase trend productivity growth noticeably over the next decade.

The post-liberal critique does indeed identify many areas of genuine concern, but it does not tell the whole story – namely, that wealthy democratic societies are doing better than ever across many important and broad measures. For example, life expectancy in the United States is rising again, after a dip during the pandemic, and is higher now than it was during the 1990s, when support for neoliberalism was at its peak. Moreover, the mortality rate from heart disease in the US fell by 66% from 1970 to 2022, while the country’s rate of violent crime has been halved over the past three decades.