A jury has convicted East Forsyth High School music teacher Winston Stevens Jr. on three counts of taking indecent liberties with a 16-year-old male student.

Text messages calling the victim his ‘stud muffin’ and ‘manly man’ certainly didn’t help, but his defense attorney did his best to discredit the timeline during which the victims say the alleged indecent liberties took place. But he had another card up his sleeve:

The student had testified that Stephens had gotten aroused during some of the alleged incidents, but Stephens and his wife, Sheryl Stephens, testified that Stephens has erectile dysfunction.

Stephens faces up to six years in prison following his conviction.